(report missings or errors to sylvie.ricard-blum:at:univ-lyon1.fr)
mzML [handling editors: Norman Paton / Christian Stephan]
final (ver 1.0.0): June 1st, 2008
update, begin of public and external review phase: April 17th, 2009
update, final (ver 1.1.0): June 1st, 2009
without DocProc?: update of index wrapper schema (ver 1.1.1.): June 1st, 2010
MIAPE Column Chromatography [handling editor: Norman Paton]
PEFF community practice document [handling editor: Norman Paton]
submission (v1.0-1): August 14th, 2008
Resubmission as a new proposal (1.0.): April 3rd, 2018 [handling editor: Sylvie Ricard-Blum]
Start of 30-days steering group comment phase: April 4th, 2018
Deadline for corrections and comments: May 4th, 2018
Suggested minor changes: January 22nd, 2019
Start of 60-days public and external phase review: January 25th, 2019
End of the 60-days public and external phase review: March 25th, 2019.
Submission of the revised version: April 5th, 2019
Approval by external reviewers: April 20th, 2019
Finalization of specification document /specification document available: April 24th, 2019
Final announcement via mailing list: April 2019
MIAPE Gel Informatics [handling editor: Norman Paton]
AnalysisXML / mzIdentML [handling editors: Norman Paton / Christian Stephan]
begin of external and public review (AnalysisXML): February 27th, 2009
final (mzIdentML ver 1.0.0): < August 13th, 2009
update, final (mzIdentML ver 1.1.0): September 12th, 2011
mzIdentML 1.2 [handling editor: Sylvie Ricard-Blum]
submission: July 27th, 2016
PSI-PAR [handling editor: Christian Stephan]
begin of external and public review: April 7th, 2009
final: < August 13th, 2009
TraML [handling editor: Christian Stephan]
mzQuantML [first handling editor: Christian Stephan]
submitted (ver 1.0.0-rc1): August 2011
begin of external and public review: December 12th, 2011
end of external and public review: Feb / March 2012?
[acting handling editor from Nov 2012 onwards, Pierre-Alain Binz]
resubmission (ver 1.0.0-rc2): June 2012
resubmission (ver 1.0.0-rc3) in response to minor corrections
final release (ver 1.0.0): February 2nd, 2013
mzQuantML 1.0.1 [handling editor: Martin Eisenacher]
submission: March 19th, 2015
consideration of changes, decision: minor update from 1.0.0 to 1.0.1
begin of 14-days public comment phase: March 27th, 2015
deadline for corrections and comments: April 12th, 2015
incorporation of minor comments: April 2015
finalization of specification document / migration of files to github / specification document available: October 2015
final announcement via mailing list: January 2016
MIAPE-MS update type b [handling editor: Martin Eisenacher]
submission (ver 2.97.8): before April 2012
begin of external and public review: June 4th, 2012
(comments received from two invited reviewers and two journal editors as public reviewers)
end of external and public review: July 16th, 2012
revision (version 2.98): July 24th, 2012
final (version 2.98): August 15th, 2012
MIAPE-Quant [handling editors: Christian Stephan / Martin Eisenacher]
submission of version 0.9.1
begin of external and public review: February 22nd, 2012
(July 2012: prolongation of public and external review due to web page problems and lack of reviews)
(comments received from two invited and one public reviewer => major revisions)
end of external and public review: August, 14th, 2012
major revision (version 0.9.2_RC) sent into shortend "14 day public review": September 17th, 2012
accepted: October 18th, 2012; final version 1.0 released on October 24th, 2012)
mzTab [handling editor: Martin Eisenacher]
submission: June 7th, 2012
end steering commitee review: August 1st, 2012
begin of external and public review: August 13th, 2012
(comments received from two invited reviewers, one steering committee member, and two public commenters => major revision)
end of external and public review: November 5th, 2012 (was prolonged, first deadline: October 12th, 2012)
begin of 14-days-resubmission R2 external and public review: March 10th, 2013
end of 14-days-resubmission R2 external and public review: March 24th, 2013
(comments received from two invited reviewers, one steering committee member, and four public commenters => minor revision, then Final after Editor approval)
re-submission of R3: December 2013 (unexpected restructuring => previous decision changed to major revision and 30-days public and external review)
begin of 30-days-resubmission R3 external and public review: after Christmas break 2014
end of 30-days-resubmission R3 external and public review: April 4th, 2014 (prolonged twice, first deadline: February 14th, 2014)
(comments received from one invited reviewers and three of the previous commenters => minor revision, wait for changes due to journal reviewers, then Final after Editor Approval)
re-submission of R4: June 20th, 2014 (minor changes after DocProc review and journal review)
After inspection of changes by PSI editor recommendation to the steering committee on August 20th, 2014: accept the mzTab specification R4 without further changes.
acceptance: September 2nd, 2014 (final version 1.0.0 as of June 20th, 2014 was announced September 15th, 2014)
proBED [handling editor: Martin Eisenacher]
original submission: July 7th, 2016
end of steering commitee review: August 22nd, 2016 (minor changes requested)
begin of 60-days public and invited review phase: October 20th, 2016
end of 60-days public and invited review: December 19th, 2016
(comments received from two invited reviewers and one public commenter => request: implementation of minor comments and validator tool for commonly expected errors, then 14-days public and invited review)
begin of 14-days-resubmission R1 public and invited review: February 27th, 2017
deadline for 14-days-resubmission R1 public and invited review: March 13th, 2017
acceptance: final version 1.0.0 as of March 13th, 2017 (was announced April 13th, 2017)
proBAM [handling editor: Martin Eisenacher]
original submission: December 21th, 2016
end of steering commitee review: February 13th, 2017 (minor changes requested, to be implemented before public review phase)
begin of 60-days public and invited review: March 30th, 2017
end of 60-days public and invited review: May 31st, 2017
(comments received from three invited reviewers and one public commenter, suggestion to steering group: implementation of major changes, then 3-weeks public and re-invitation of reviewers for revised version)
begin of 3-weeks-resubmission R1 public and invited review: October 25th, 2017
end of 3-weeks-resubmission R1 public and invited review: November 15th, 2017
(comments received from the reviewers, suggestion to steering group: implement the last change request, no further review)
acceptance of resubmission R2, switch document status to Version 1.0.0 FINAL: December 1st, 2017 (will be announced after synchronized journal publication)
in FINAL document after synchronized journal publication goo.gl short URLs have been changed to point to zipped versions of example files (January 2018)
announced 14th March 2018
PSI-MI XML 3.0 [handling editor: Martin Eisenacher]
original submission: June 7th, 2017
end of steering commitee review: July 19th, 2017 (shortened SG review) (minor changes requested, to be implemented before public review phase)
begin of 60-days public and invited review: July 28th, 2017
end of 60-days public and invited review: October 17th, 2017
(comments received from three invited reviewers => request: “minor changes” from the authors which the editor will review after resubmission - no further review by invited reviewers and the public)
resubmission: February 18th, 2018 (also having synchronized with journal publication)
small changes due to editor (readability)
specification set to final: April 5th, 2018
mzTab-M 2.0 FOR METABOLOMICS [handling editor: Sylvie Ricard-Blum with Warwick Dunn as a de facto MSI Editor]
Original submission: October 31st, 2018
End of steering committee review: November 30th, 2018 (minor changes requested)
Comments received from one invited reviewer: minor changes requested from the authors. Changes following the PSI review were synchronized with those suggested by the reviewers of Analytical Chemistry
Resubmission: March 15th, 2019
Specification set to final: March 28th, 2019
Universal Spectrum Identifier (USI) [handling editor: Martin Eisenacher]
original submission: July 10th, 2020
end of steering commitee review: August 17th, 2020 (minor changes requested, to be implemented before the public review phase)
begin of 60-days public and invited review: October 19th, 2020
end of 60-days public and invited review: December 18th, 2020 (discussed recommendations to authors with steering group, sent comments and recommendations to authors in January 2021)
resubmission, check of changes by reviewers: July 15th, 2021
finalization of standard: July, 22nd 2021
mzQC - quality control [handling editor: Martin Eisenacher, then Sylvie Ricard-Blum]
original submission: December 13th, 2020
end of steering committee review: February 3rd, 2021 (some changes requested to authors in February 2021 to be OKed by the specific SC reviewers before going on to the next phase)
<editor switch to Sylvie Ricard-Blum>
MI-TAB 2.8 [handling editor: Martin Eisenacher]
original submission: March 22nd, 2021
no steering commitee review, because minor update (only small formatting changes requested by PSI editor)
begin of 60-days public and invited review: April 26th, 2021
end of public and invited review: August 9th (was delayed because it was difficult to find reviewers); some questions / change requests, at least those of reviewers 2 and 3 will be send to them for re-review.
Proforma 2.0 [handling editor: Sylvie Ricard-Blum]
Original submission: October 24th, 2020
Start of 30-days steering group comment phase: October 24th, 2020
Deadline for corrections and comments: November 24th, 2020
Suggested minor changes: revised version submitted on December 18th, 2020
Start of 60-days public and external phase review: December 26th, 2020
End of the 60-days public and external phase review, extended upon a reviewer's request: March 19th, 2021
Submission of the revised version: November 29th, 2021
Approval by external reviewers: February 2nd, 2022
Finalization of specification document: February 3rd, 2022
Specification document available: March, 13th 2022
Final announcement via mailing list: March, 2022
mzPAF [handling editor: Sylvie Ricard-Blum]
Original submission (draft 09, version 1.0): January 23rd, 2023
Start of the 14-day review by the steering committee: January 29th, 2023
Deadline for corrections and comments: February 12th, 2023
Minor changes suggested on February 7th, 2023
Revised version (draft 10, version 1.0) submitted on February 25th, 2023
Start of the 45-day public and external review: March 3rd, 2023
End of the 45-day public and external review: April 18th, 2023
SDRF [handling editor: Sylvie Ricard-Blum]
Original submission (draft, version 1.0): November 27th, 2020
Start of 30-day review by the steering committee: December 6th, 2020
Deadline for corrections and comments: January 6th, 2021
Minor changes suggested on January 7th, 2021 - Revised version (draft, version 1.0 ): March, 25th 2021
Start of the 60-day public and external review: April 24th, 2021
End of the 60-day public and external review: June 30th, 2021 - Reviewer comments sent to the authors on July, 16th, 2021, August 2nd, 2021
Revised version of SDRF-Proteomics (draft, version 1.0): May 6th, 2023 - Responses to the comments of all the reviewers and to public comments: May 15th, 2023
Minor changes requested by the editor: May 23rd, 2023
Finalization of the specification document approved by the editor: May 24th, 2023
Final announcement via mailing lists: June 2023